ptahrrific: Jon and Stephen, "Believe in the me who believes in you" (fake news)
Erin Ptah ([personal profile] ptahrrific) wrote2007-09-30 12:07 am

Fake News: The Thing With Feathers, Chapter 7

Title: The Thing With Feathers, Chapter 7
Fandom: The Daily Show/The Colbert Report
Rating: PG
Words: ~1900
Disclaimer: Two.

For the Report characters: They and their universe are property of Stephen Colbert, the other Report writers, and of course Viacom. Not mine. Sue me not, please.

And for the real people, the poem:
Please, make no mistake:
these people aren't fake,
but what's said here is no more than fiction.
It only was writ
because we like their wit
and wisecracks, and pull-squints, and diction.
We don't mean to quibble,
but this can't be libel;
it's never implied to be real.
No disrespect's meant;
if you disapprove, then,
the back button's right up there. Deal.

Notes: Makes time-and-space-travel references to Narnia, Stargate, Sliders, and Doctor Who.

For the full table of contents, click here.

The Thing With Feathers
Chapter 7



(there.)


During the ride back to the studio, Stephen peppered Jon with questions; a screen had gone up behind the front seat, so they could be candid without freaking out the driver. The potential horror of his situation had been thrust out of his mind by the more immediate concern of how he was going to handle the Report.

"It sounds like it's exactly the thing my show pretends to be," he said at last. "Wait. How does the Wørd work?"

"Um. It's kind of like O'Reilly's 'Talking Points Memo' feature; Stephen talks about an issue that's on his mind, and this bullet point on half of the screen summarizes or rephrases important points."

"So it just summarizes?"

"Or rephrases, yes. Why, what does yours do?"

Stephen grinned. "It makes snarky comebacks."

"What do you mean?"

"Oh, it's great. I make some ridiculous argument, and the bullet mocks it. Or pokes it full of holes. Or just basically provides a running Mystery Science Theater commentary on what I'm saying. It's always the favorite feature when we poll the viewers -- they go wild when the graphic comes on."

"You've lost me," admitted Jon.

"I'll give you an example. So today, the wørd was 'White Guy'. And I, in-character, made this whole argument about how John Edwards should declare himself a black woman to get fundraising dollars, right? So I say that, and the bullet says, 'Republicans Already Declared Themselves Reagan.'"

It was dark out on the highway, but he could see that Jon was nodding, so he pressed on. "And I say, 'Who spends four hundred dollars on their hair? Girls.' And the bullet says, 'And Stephen.'"

"He does do that," said Jon; Stephen could hear the smile in his voice.

"And then I say, 'There have been all these debates on whether Barack Obama is really black; well, let's start one on whether John Edwards is.' And the bullet goes 'Hint: No.'"

Now this Jon was all-out giggling, the same way the real one did, and Stephen felt encouraged, energized. He could do this. This version of his staff, and this audience, and this Nation, would pose no problem for him; he could make this Jon laugh.

"It works with other topics, too," he went on. "When that guy from NASA made the really absurd comments about global warming, I agreed, 'It's arrogant to try to stop climate change until you've asked all other human beings what they think, and how could we possibly know what the other people in the world think about global warming?' and the bullet goes 'Kyoto Treaty Signatories' and this list of countries starts racing past."

Jon was doubled over with laughter, shaking from it; Stephen laughed too as he plunged ahead.

"We did this one about Freud, a while back, where I was insisting that I don't have a subconscious and none of his theories apply to me. So I say, 'I take personal responsibility for every decision I make,' and the bullet goes, 'Really? That Tie?' And then I go on to say 'I'm not against gay marriage because I'm secretly afraid I'm gay,' and the bullet reads 'Secretly Knows He's Gay.' And I--"

He stopped, because Jon had suddenly been seized by a choking fit.

"You all right there?" asked Stephen, reaching out. Jon batted his hand away.

"Fine -- I'm fine -- what did it say?"

"The bullet? It said ... Oh. Oh. I forgot -- he's real to you, I can't go outing him, I've got to be more careful -- I'm sorry, but didn't you already know? I mean, he's not exactly subtle about it..."

"He isn't," admitted Jon. "But he thinks he hides it well -- this is so weird, hearing you just come out and say it, you have no idea."

"I can imagine."

Jon didn't reply to that, and Stephen didn't know what else to say. He wanted desperately to go back to the joking and laughing, but the moment was gone.

"So," he tried, switching topics, "The Daily Show. For you, it's a real news program?"

"Well, yes. We call it alternative news, but it's real. What's your version?"

"Fake news."

"Oh, you make up stories?"

"No, they cover real ones; but it's more important to be funny than to be right. And you have to watch the actual news to get the facts so that you understand the jokes. But you guys are real journalists; you must actually fact-check."

"Er," said Jon. "Officially, our fact-checker is on sabbatical. Unofficially, we cannot in fact afford one."

"Oh. But you send correspondents to report on-location? We mostly use a green screen and stock footage."

"Well. If you must know, we use a green screen too. Saves energy, and transportation costs."

Stephen frowned. "Then you at least do original research?"

"I ... uh ... sometimes. We'll send correspondents off to do field pieces and original interviews. But a lot of what we do is just piggybacking on what the major networks cover."

"Wow," said Stephen.

"What do you mean, 'wow'?"

"It's just, it sounds like you do exactly the same thing that we do in my universe, except that we don't pretend to have any credibility."

"It doesn't really matter," said Jon quickly. "The show is never taken seriously anyway."

"You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is."


---------------------
---------------------

(here.)


Jon took a step towards the desk, but Allison put a hand on his shoulder. "Hang on. Maybe one of us should do it."

"Not me," said Eric quickly. "You know how he treats Bobby. Actually, if you don't mind, I'm gonna go online and google Vicodin withdrawal."

"Good call," said Jon. "Okay, Al, you talk to him. See if you can work out how he got here."

And as she approached Stephen he followed, a couple of steps behind.


---------------------


Stephen was trying to wrap his head around reality again, and with the sweet taste of his pills still on his tongue it was coming together. Obviously, there weren't bats in the studio. There was no one but Jon, Bobby, and Allison, whispering to each other.

What are they whispering? What are they plotting?

They can't be plotting, he told himself. Not against him. Bobby wanted his next paycheck, and ladies didn't do that sort of thing, and Jon, well, Jon was kind of like a lady that way.

But after what you did in the office, Jon would be entirely justified in doing, well, almost anything.

A good point. How could he have misread the situation so badly?

He led you on, he was dropping hints, being provocative on purpose, it's part of the agenda, he's in on it...

And, come to think of it, the three of them had done a lot of whispering even before then, when Jon had first arrived.

You see? It was all a trap!

But Jon wouldn't do that. Stephen couldn't believe it. Not Jon.

He was in the middle of this mental round of Formidable Opponent when Allison walked up and leaned against the desk. "Stephen, do you know how you got here?"

"What do you mean? How I got to this desk, how I got this show, how I came to be on this Earth? There was this party, and my parents decided to have a good time, and things got frisky..."

"No, no, I don't need to hear about that," said Allison quickly. "What I mean is -- have you walked into any magical wardrobes lately?"

Stephen frowned. "Not that I know of. Why, is there one around here?"

"Not here, no. But I'm sure you've noticed that things have been different for at least a few hours now. The show isn't running when you thought it would. I'm here. Eric is Eric, not Bobby. Have you noticed other things?"

Now that she mentioned it... "Some of the pictures in my office are missing."

"Really? Which ones?"

"Most of the good ones of me. I was going to ask if some fans had snuck in and stolen them. It's the kind of thing my fans might do."

"That makes sense," mused Allison. "You would have more self-portraits than he does."

"Than who does?"

Allison pressed her fingertips together in concentration. At last she said, "Is the phrase 'parallel universe' in your vocabulary?"

"Do I look like a brainiac on the nerd patrol?"

"No, but you're a Lord of the Rings fan. There's a geeky streak in you somewhere."

She had him there. "Of course I know what a parallel universe is," snapped Stephen. "Don't patronize me."

"Here's the thing, then. As far as we can tell, you're from one."

"What?"

"This isn't your universe. You've ... hopped realities, somehow. We know a Stephen Colbert, but he's, er, let's just say he's very different from you. This is his desk. That's his office. Eric and I, we work for him."

Stephen found himself once again in the position of trying to reset his view of reality. "That's impossible," he said at last. "I'm me. And if this is some other Stephen's universe, and he's so different, why is my studio the same?"

"Our Stephen does the Report too. It's, well, again, it's different, but the visuals are the same. Everything on the set looks the same; it's when you get to the stuff off-camera that you should start to notice differences. In your office. In the halls. We don't have a Colbunker, either."

Stephen considered this. That would explain why the doorway to the secret elevator had gone missing. And the pictures...

"So, again, any wardrobes? Shiny round gates? Magic spells? Long silver tunnels? Police boxes that are bigger on the inside? In short, have you done anything recently that might lead to -- man, I can't believe I'm really asking this -- interdimensional travel?"

He couldn't think of anything, of course. It was an absurd question.

Come to think of it, the whole idea was absurd. He didn't care that it fit the facts. This room was called the No Fact Zone for a reason. "I haven't done anything, and I don't know why I'm listening to this," he declared. "Maybe you're just trying to confuse me. Maybe you're behind this all. Who are you, really? Jon, who is she?"

"She's exactly who she says she is," replied Jon from behind her. "And she's telling the truth, as far as we can figure it out. You're not the Stephen we know."

"How can you be so sure?" demanded Stephen.

"Well, for one thing, our Stephen wouldn't jump me in the office."

Stephen was on his feet so quickly that his chair went crashing backwards.

In one cold moment his eyes flashed between Jon's face (unsympathetic) to Allison's (unsurprised), and all at once he understood that both of them were strangers.

"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon."

And with that he bolted for the office, because even though it wasn't his office, it still had a lock.

[identity profile] winged-mammal.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 04:39 am (UTC)(link)
I was finally able to sit down and read this from the beginning today. And... wow. Just wow. Anything I could say has probably been said already, but I'm just in love with every aspect of this story. The whole premise is fascinating, and it's executed so well with a wonderful blend of humor and seriousness, and you really do get deep down into everybody's and "everybody's" psyches which (as I see happened with last chapter) really makes you think about "Stephen" and how his world is and relates to this one.

In short, I'm glad this is already all written. 'Cause I don't know if I could handle much waiting. XD

[identity profile] tomephile.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 04:40 am (UTC)(link)
Favourite part:

"It's just, it sounds like you do exactly the same thing that we do in my universe, except that we don't pretend to have any credibility."

"It doesn't really matter," said Jon quickly. "The show is never taken seriously anyway."

"You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is."

I love "Stephen" so much in this. He's a bastard, but he's a bastard who could potentially reform. I can't wait to find out how the Stephens switched universes.

[identity profile] shruti-42.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 04:51 am (UTC)(link)
"You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is."

The build up to that was really well executed. Good job.


Also, poor "Stephen."

[identity profile] gaiafaye.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 04:54 am (UTC)(link)
I love when I forget about this fic, because when it pops up on my flist it's a fabulous surprise.

"Most of the good ones of me. I was going to ask if some fans had snuck in and stolen them. It's the kind of thing my fans might do."

Please tell me you're going to have a scene where Stephen is accosted by "Stephen's" fans, because it would be priceless. Or terrifying. Probably terrifying. Okay, definitely terrifying.

I'm thinking "Stephen" encountering Stephen's fans could result in some fangirl tears.

"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon."

Ouch.

And now back to waiting for the next part. :(

[identity profile] imoldfashioned.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 05:04 am (UTC)(link)
Hey! You post a new chapter while I'm emailing you! No fair!

(runs off to read)

[identity profile] imoldfashioned.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 05:18 am (UTC)(link)
That whole scene in the car is fantastic--I love the comfort and joy Stephen gets from the fact that he can still make Jon laugh, no matter which universe he's inhabiting. "Stephen's" internal monologue is great too--"what are they plotting?"--and it never fails to crack me up when "Stephen" uses the term "Lady".

Also, I have such a girl-crush on Alison Silverman it's not even funny. She's so cool and smart and she has, like, the best job in the world. It's nice to see her in a more major role than she's usually cast.

Can't wait for the next chapter.

(no subject)

[personal profile] deepad - 2008-12-31 03:26 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] ediblestars.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 05:18 am (UTC)(link)
Oh my god. I love you for this, so much. I love the way both sections ended, very clever and poignant, and I have to commend this:

In one cold moment his eyes flashed between Jon's face (unsympathetic) to Allison's (unsurprised), and all at once he understood that both of them were strangers.

"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can
trust my Jon."

The layers here--to say nothing of the emotions--are amazing. I can't wait to see where this goes!

[identity profile] alivemagdolene.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 05:25 am (UTC)(link)
Or just basically provides a running Mystery Science Theater commentary on what I'm saying.

Oh, GODS. MST3k reference!!!! *collapses in MSTie delight* I was almost going to comment on that, then finish reading and post a comment on the whole fic, but I restrained myself. Barely.

"We did this one about Freud, a while back, where I was insisting that I don't have a subconscious and none of his theories apply to me.["]

That's my favorite Wørd ever, directly after "Hell, No!". I had never before thought of The Wørd as kin to MST3k, but now it's undeniable. And easily one reason I love The Wørd so very muchly.

"It doesn't really matter," said Jon quickly. "The show is never taken seriously anyway."

"You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is."


Brilliant, once again. :^)

"Well, for one thing, our Stephen wouldn't jump me in the office."

Stephen was on his feet so quickly that his chair went crashing backwards.

In one cold moment his eyes flashed between Jon's face (unsympathetic) to Allison's (unsurprised), and all at once he understood that both of them were strangers.

"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon."


Awww, mine heart snapped in half for "Stephen". :^(

Next-chapter-eagerness abounds!!! :^D



[identity profile] foureyedsnail.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 06:04 am (UTC)(link)
I can't remember if I left a comment for the last chapter: if I didn't, know that I typed a comment for the last chapter, and then got attacked by orientation week and kidnapped off to some lecture or meeting with a professor or various hazing activity. I can't keep my head on straight these days.

Magical wardrobe love!!!

And also, I concur with the above, the end of that scene in the car is just perfect. I am intrigued to hear more about TDS-the-real-news-show, and whether Jon is as funny, and who follows it, and how serious it is and everything. :D

Poooor "Stephen." He is indeed so fragile, and the WHOLE WORLD IS SHAKING. *pats*

[identity profile] unabstruse.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 06:49 am (UTC)(link)
Your scenes with Jon admitting that he's kind of a fraud *there* and that end scene with Stephen *here*.... oh my goodness. Drama and pain and mystery, oh my! You are the full 31 flavours, m'dear- thank you for writing! (And updating before I went to bed :)

[identity profile] http://users.livejournal.com/_lady_vanilla_/ 2007-09-30 09:18 am (UTC)(link)
Haha, I'll tell you why I didn't comment last time. It was because the more I thought through this story, the more my brain exploded. I started to consider "Jon" and how he is clearly trying to be funny because he's himself on the show, and how in "Stephen's" world how that wouldn't work because it's comedy but it's not for the Report, but if it was a matter of taking the mannerisms of your comedic routine, he would be somewhat stupid, kind of an ass and probably not liked...

So yeah. Brain explodey. But I love your description in this chapter about how the Daily Show works in this world. =)

The part where Stephen is telling all his jokes to "Jon" is lovely. I'm worried "Jon" is going to want to go back with him, though. Oh and have I mentioned you've got "Stephen" down perfectly? =D

[identity profile] girlgeekwankery.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 09:24 am (UTC)(link)
"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon."

That broke my heart. Poor "Stephen".

And I love the interaction between "Jon" and Stephen.

Ah, I love this story! I'm worried about the Stephens doing one another's shows. *flails a little and goes back to bed*

[identity profile] nacchi-camui.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 09:37 am (UTC)(link)
Well it went way better than I thought with "Stephen" ! (in my head it was rather around the lines of "come on, Stephen, you know you're not really that douchebag, he doesn't even exist !")
I'm glad Allison and Jon figured it out too. Now quite everybody can move from 'what the hell' to 'how to hell'~

The whole car scene was pretty funny. Stephen and "Jon" are adorable together, of course, two sweetie pies in the same place.

Also, I was a Sliders addict *sigh* The last season was so lame.

[identity profile] violent-rabbit.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 09:48 am (UTC)(link)
You break my heart in every chapter. Poor Stepehn. I cant really say anything that everyone above has said already. So, Instead, here is some love:


*LOVES ON THIS*

[identity profile] michablack.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 12:04 pm (UTC)(link)
Ahh, it's always good to see a new chapter of this... They've already been mentioned, but the lines "You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is." and "You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon." (Ow) are really great, and the characterization continues to be very interesting.


(Read and enjoyed the last chapter too, btw, just didn't have anything particularly clever to comment with because it was a brilliant chapter that deserved more than just "yay, good chapter!")

[identity profile] kahvi.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 05:03 pm (UTC)(link)
It's the iPhone, isn't it?

(More comments later - just came home from a weekend trip and rushed to read this.)

(no subject)

[identity profile] kahvi.livejournal.com - 2007-09-30 19:53 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] kahvi.livejournal.com - 2007-09-30 21:10 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] kahvi.livejournal.com - 2007-09-30 21:38 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] ayn-rand-fan-13.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 08:45 pm (UTC)(link)
I haven't commented yet, but I am completely in love with this story. Like, a lot. As in I've pretty much been rereading it for a good part of my day.
I normally hate stories with character Stephen, but it ultimately sucked me in.
I really wasn't expecting to like "Stephen" so much, but I kind of love him. And everybody else in the story, really.

[identity profile] belmanoir.livejournal.com 2007-09-30 10:43 pm (UTC)(link)
Now this Jon was all-out giggling, the same way the real one did, and Stephen felt encouraged, energized. He could do this. This version of his staff, and this audience, and this Nation, would pose no problem for him; he could make this Jon laugh.

AWWW! Stephen and his making-Jon-laugh thing is my favorite thing in the whole world.

Also, why is Jon being such a dick to "Stephen"? I mean, it sucks for him that his friend is missing, and "Stephen" is an ass, but it still makes me sad.

[identity profile] beebee852001.livejournal.com 2007-10-01 04:23 pm (UTC)(link)
I wasn't sure what the Daily Show would be like in the other world, I feel sorry for "Jon", the idea of them being another rubbish news show, something that he can't really be proud of or anything. I love him giggling at Stephen though, so cute :D Poor "Stephen", i'm worried about him still, I don't want him to have a major freak-out.

This is still awesome :D

[identity profile] darkfaery1.livejournal.com 2007-10-02 01:57 am (UTC)(link)
Sorry all my comments are so short, but at least I'm all caught up!

You already know how much I like the way you write "Stephen", but you can add Stephen and the two Jon's to that as well. I did think it was kinda mean of Jon to 'out' "Stephen", but I doubt Jon would understand how hurtful that would be for him. Of course, Jon sees him as a two-demensional jerk with no feelings. Oh, how wrong he is--about the feelings part.=)

Man, I adore this story. Can't wait for the next chapter!

(no subject)

[identity profile] darkfaery1.livejournal.com - 2007-10-02 02:51 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] darkfaery1.livejournal.com - 2007-10-02 02:56 (UTC) - Expand

[identity profile] crackt3h2nd.livejournal.com 2007-10-03 10:21 am (UTC)(link)
"It doesn't really matter," said Jon quickly. "The show is never taken seriously anyway."

"You know what's weird?" replied Stephen. "In my world, it is."


I'm not sure if this would offend you, but I was forcibly reminded of that Crossfire ep with Jon in it. I also remember the shooting for the opening of the TDS: Global Edition, where Jon says it's not real. It really is sort of sad that some actually take the show as their source of news. I think it signifies the lost of trust of the real media covering the headlines. If something like this happened in my country, I wouldn't be surprised.


"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon."

And with that he bolted for the office, because even though it wasn't his office, it still had a lock.


He reminds me of a seven year old child. No wait, that was insulting. He reminds me of a five/two year old child. I feel bad for the man. He's just this large basketcase GREENDAYYAY! that's waiting to break-up. I'm wondering if there would be a 'talk' scene like the one in 'Expecting', even if it was only mentioned in passing.

I know I'm not much of a help, but I am not a good critic. Except to myself. And Fall Out Of Pants Boy. Maybe even Frerard Gay. I dunno. But let me say this: This fic is as emotionally turbulent as a fic can get.... Not even sure if I said that right.

(no subject)

[identity profile] crackt3h2nd.livejournal.com - 2007-10-03 14:18 (UTC) - Expand

(no subject)

[identity profile] crackt3h2nd.livejournal.com - 2007-10-03 14:35 (UTC) - Expand
acorn_squash: an acorn (Default)

[personal profile] acorn_squash 2025-04-12 03:57 am (UTC)(link)
I love the moment when Stephen suddenly realizes that to “Jon,” “Stephen” is a real person and he shouldn’t out him.

"You are not my Jon," he hissed. "I can trust my Jon.”


…Oh no.

(Turns out, [in the context of this fic,] “Stephen” is a real person and you shouldn’t out him!)